There seems to be a pervading sense in many CSR circles that there is now business consensus about the most pressing issues in our global society, taking their cues from the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), the Global Compact and other such frameworks. While many of the issues remain difficult to deal with in practice, companies are credited with putting strategies in place for tackling them. Everything, they argue, is going according to plan; hence, there is no need for anything more dramatic, especially not legislation to enforce improved performance. Or is there?
There is another perspective, which enjoys far less air time. A perspective that says the world is in a deepening crisis of alarming proportions and that the private sector’s response, under the guise of CSR, is as effective as placing a band aid on the foot of someone who is haemorrhaging from a head wound. This alternative perspective, radical as it sounds, nevertheless seems to be confirmed by just about every available statistic on the ecological and social health of our global society.
The question then becomes: is CSR, as it is currently being preached and practiced by multinational corporations around the world, actually a red herring? Is it a distraction from the more fundamental transformation (perhaps revolution even) of the capitalist business model which is needed? And as CSR becomes an established professional practice, will it take as given that its purpose is to benefit those who employ its professionals, rather than a primary goal of transforming the world?
If so, CSR will have contributed towards a global ‘Crash and Burn’ scenario, with growing ecological and social degradation.
Wayne Visser is Founder and CEO of CSR International and the author/editor of six books, including five on the role of business in society, the most recent of which are Making A Difference and The A to Z of Corporate Social Responsibility.
CSR International is a media sponsor of NEW MODELS OF SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY: A GLOBAL VIRTUAL SUMMIT, Nov. 5 and 9, 2009. Register at www.communitelligence.com.